When little Lucy wishes it were Christmas every day, "forever and ever", her dad tells the cautionary tale of her grandmother Tilly, who, as a little girl, made the very same wish, and the dire consequences that occurred after her wish was granted.

• CBS Studios
• Orkin-Flaum Productions
• Stacey Michaels
• Brian Cummings
• Miriam Flynn
• Edie McClurg
• Marla Frumkin
• Dick Orkin
• Nancy Cartwright